• Home
    • Norf'k Ilen's Language
    • Algae
    • Corals
    • Eels
    • Everything Else
    • Kingston, Norfolk Island
    • Nudibranchs, Sea Slugs and Flatworms
    • Octopuses
    • Out On A Swim Index
    • Reef Fish
    • Sharks
    • Sea Anemones
    • Sea Stars
    • Sea Urchins and Sea Cucumbers
    • Turtles
    • Underwater
    • Videos
  • Out on a swim - blog
  • About
  • Contact + Subscribe
Menu

Norfolk Island's Reef

Discover a fragile paradise – Norfolk Island's beaches, lagoons and coral reef
  • Home
  • Explore
    • Norf'k Ilen's Language
    • Algae
    • Corals
    • Eels
    • Everything Else
    • Kingston, Norfolk Island
    • Nudibranchs, Sea Slugs and Flatworms
    • Octopuses
    • Out On A Swim Index
    • Reef Fish
    • Sharks
    • Sea Anemones
    • Sea Stars
    • Sea Urchins and Sea Cucumbers
    • Turtles
    • Underwater
    • Videos
  • Out on a swim - blog
  • About
  • Contact + Subscribe

Out on A Swim

‘Out on a swim’ is a coral reef blog that tells the stories of the characters who live under the waves and what has caught my eye when ‘out on a swim’ in the lagoons of Norfolk Island. It is also a record of the difficulties Norfolk Island’s reef faces, like many others around the world, as a result of the poor water quality that has been allowed to flow onto it.

This page shows the most recent blog posts. For the complete catalogue, visit the ‘Out on a swim index’ page.

This blog is rated in the Top 20 Coral Reef Blogs in the world.

No results found

Slaughter Bay, Norfolk Island

What Norfolk Island’s reef tells us about environmental blind spots

April 5, 2026

Why the Kingston dredging proposal may have needed a more rigorous assessment

Most people are unlikely to spend much time thinking about the difference between a Public Environment Report (PER) and an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). On paper, both are formal assessment pathways under the EPBC system. But the distinction between these two processes is important. In the case of the Kingston dredging proposal, the Department assessed the project through a Public Environment Report, or PER, rather than requiring an Environmental Impact Statement, or EIS.

The Department’s current guidance says it uses a PER, where it needs a narrower and less encompassing scope than an EIS. It also says the choice of assessment method depends on how extensive the likely impacts are, how complex the action is, and the comments received.

That is where Norfolk Island becomes interesting.

Back in 2023, before I was a PhD candidate, I wrote from a place of frustration and instinct about a problem I could see but could not yet fully articulate:

  • how can protections work properly if we do not know what is there

  • or if what is there is not well recognised by the systems meant to assess risk?

Looking back, the wording was more emotional than I would use now, but the questions were sound. That article can be found here: Tiptoeing through the government silos.

Then there is the Protected Matters Search Tool, or PMST, which is often used in PERs and EISs. This is the Australian Government’s online screening tool under the EPBC framework. It is designed to help identify protected matters that may occur in or near a project area, so it can help shape environmental referrals, risk screening and assessment at an early stage. In other words, it is one of the tools used to help frame what ‘matters’ may need attention in all kinds of proposals – such as the Norfolk Island’s Kingston dredging project. The Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW) makes clear that any PMST information is indicative only and not exhaustive. The PMST is an issue, linked to the type of assessment that is called for by the which is is really another version of the same problem.

To the west of Kingston Pier, the site of the planned dredging, Norfolk Island

Looking from Point Hunter towards Kingston Pier, down the length of the inshore reef and lagoon of Emily and Slaughter Bays, Norfolk Island

The Kingston Pier proposal was not beside some isolated and anonymous stretch of coastline. The PER itself says the most accessible reefs in the Norfolk Island coral reef ecosystem include Emily Bay and Slaughter Bay, and that the Slaughter Bay reef is the reef most proximate to the proposed works. It also says those reefs were already under particular stress from bleaching, inshore pollution, declining water quality associated with high rainfall and land-based runoff, and a coral disease outbreak.

The same report describes Norfolk’s coral communities as one of the southern-most coral assemblages in the world, one of the few known examples of a transitional algae and coral assemblage, and a unique association of tropical and temperate species of global biodiversity value. It also says they are vulnerable to disturbance.

But here is the problem. The report also admits that ‘few systematic surveys, and no long-term monitoring of biodiversity, has occurred for the shallow water reef habitats around Norfolk Island’. It says coral spawning dates are based on anecdotal evidence from local reports and that no dedicated studies have been undertaken to determine the full duration of the spawning season or which species are involved each time. It also says the wave and dredge plume models were not verified with local wave and current measurement data because those data were not available.

Norfolk Island’s inshore coral reef

That is not the language that you would use with a well-understood ecosystem. It is the language used when there are gaps and uncertainty. We have barely scratched the surface of our knowledge gaps, so perhaps being uncertain is a wise postion for Advisian to take in its PER to the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts (DITRDCSA) regarding the Kingston dredging project.

More recently, that line of thought was sharpened by a note circulated by coral reef researcher Dr Jennie Mallela to Australian Coral Reef Society members; she raised concerns about PMST outputs for Christmas Island and the possibility that reef habitats and benthic species were not being clearly captured there either. That prompted me to look more closely at what the tool was actually showing for Norfolk Island.

As I noted above, DCCEEW says PMST information is not exhaustive. This is an important point, especially in remote territories. When I ran PMST reports for Norfolk Island generally, for the Kingston / Emily Bay / Slaughter Bay area, and for a wider marine buffer, the reports clearly returned the standard protected-matters categories. What they did not clearly surface were things such as shallow reef habitat near the project area, benthic reef communities, Norfolk-specific reef distinctiveness, or the ecological significance of the project-adjacent reef itself.

That points to a deeper problem. PMST is built to surface matters recognised under the EPBC framework. That is useful as far as it goes, but it also means the tool gives greatest visibility to what is already formally listed, mapped or categorised. If a species, habitat or assemblage is not well captured in that framework, it can become much less visible in the assessment process. That does not make it unimportant. It simply means the administrative lens is narrower than the ecology. A species does not become unimportant because it is not EPBC-listed, and a reef system does not cease to be distinctive simply because its uniqueness is not well expressed in the categories being searched. PMST is useful for surfacing listed and mapped protected matters, but it is much less effective at conveying the full significance of a benthic reef system whose importance lies in habitat, local assemblages, ecological condition, and place-specific vulnerability.

To be fair, the Kingston PER did not rely on PMST alone. It drew on broader reef science as well. But that is almost the point. If a place has to be explained through layers of supplementary ecological evidence because the standard protected-matters frame does not tell the whole story, then perhaps the assessment rung was too low for the place.

That does not mean that an EIS was legally required. The Department’s own guidance does not set out a simple and obvious test of that kind. But it does support a narrower and, in my view, stronger argument: for a remote, shallow, already stressed, ecologically distinctive reef system with limited long-term monitoring and admitted uncertainty, there was a credible case for a more intensive assessment pathway than the PER that was used.

Norfolk Island is exactly the sort of place where what matters most ecologically is not always what shows up most clearly administratively. That is why the distinction between a PER and an EIS deserves more scrutiny than it usually gets.

An as yet undescribed species of Eviota, possibly a new endemic species for Norfolk Island


Further reading

  • To dredge or not to dredge? The Kingston Pier channel project

  • Reef grief: what dredging has done to other reefs

← The lime-green coral in Slaughter Bay – a 40-year paper trailHammer coral time! →
Featured
Familiar faces – getting to know the reef’s residents
November 3, 2026
Familiar faces – getting to know the reef’s residents
November 3, 2026

Six years of swimming the same little reef have introduced me to some unforgettable characters that I’ve followed over time. From familiar fish and anemones to turtles and a snail’s eggs, this final article in my photographic series explores what I’ve learned about the lives of individual animals simply by returning, watching and taking photographs.

Read more →
November 3, 2026
When algae move in – the changing reef neighbourhood
November 1, 2026
When algae move in – the changing reef neighbourhood
November 1, 2026

Algae are a natural part of Norfolk Island's reef, changing with the underwater seasons. But sometimes their beautiful green growth conceals a rather sad story. In the fifth article of my six-part photographic series, I revisit familiar places to see how algae have changed over the years – and what might be hiding underneath.

Read more →
November 1, 2026
The slow disappearance – disease on the reef
October 30, 2026
The slow disappearance – disease on the reef
October 30, 2026

What happens after coral disease has run its course? In the fourth article of my six-part photographic series, I revisit colonies I've watched lose living tissue, sometimes alarmingly quickly. From a potentially century-old brain coral that lost most of its living tissue in less than 100 days to the algae-covered skeletons left years later, these photographs reveal the longer-term consequences of coral disease on Norfolk Island's reef.

Read more →
October 30, 2026
When storms rearrange the reef
October 28, 2026
When storms rearrange the reef
October 28, 2026

Sometimes the sea rearranges a reef in a matter of hours! In the third article of my six-part photographic series, I revisit corals broken, overturned or swept away by powerful swells and storm surges. Some disappeared altogether, while others found surprising ways to survive. Five photographic sequences reveal just how dramatically Norfolk Island's reef can change.

Read more →
October 28, 2026
When the reef fights back – coral growth and recovery
October 26, 2026
When the reef fights back – coral growth and recovery
October 26, 2026

Not every coral story ends badly! Among six years of underwater photographs are some wonderful examples of growth, survival and recovery. From corals that have grown spectacularly to others that have survived bleaching, breakage or even being turned upside down, this second article in my photographic series celebrates some of the reef's more encouraging stories.

Read more →
October 26, 2026
The neighbours – six years of watching the same reef
October 24, 2026
The neighbours – six years of watching the same reef
October 24, 2026

When I began photographing Norfolk Island's reef in 2020, I simply recorded whatever caught my eye. Six years later, those photographs have become a record of individual corals and their changing fortunes – growth, competition, survival and loss. This is the first of six articles looking back at what I've seen, and sometimes what I wish I hadn't.

Read more →
October 24, 2026
Pulling the rugosity from out of the reef
October 10, 2026
Pulling the rugosity from out of the reef
October 10, 2026

What do ‘rugosity’, structural complexity and channeling your inner fish have in common? Quite a lot, as it turns out. This week I’m looking at how all the lumps, bumps, branches, holes and ledges on a reef create habitat – with a brief detour into one of my long-standing tricks for navigating tertiary study: write down the jargon until it starts to make sense.

Read more →
October 10, 2026
How does a sea slug smell?
September 27, 2026
How does a sea slug smell?
September 27, 2026

It started with a close-up of a little Elysia and two rhinophores that looked like tiny rolled-up scrolls. Once I noticed them, I started going back through years of sea-slug photos and realised just how wildly different these sensory organs can be – ridged, rolled, curled, tubular and, in sea hares, distinctly rabbit-eared. So this week’s rabbit hole is all about how sea slugs ‘smell’ underwater, and why their noses come in so many different shapes.

Read more →
September 27, 2026
The Elite Fleet sails in
September 19, 2026
The Elite Fleet sails in
September 19, 2026

Nearly six years ago, my very first blog post was about the strange blue and violet creatures that live at the ocean’s surface – a group I christened Norfolk Island’s ‘Elite Fleet’. Since then I’ve seen plenty of bluebottles and the occasional violet sea snail, but never a by-the-wind sailor. Until this morning. Velella velella is not a true jellyfish, but a colonial hydrozoan with a transparent sail that lets the wind help carry it across the ocean. So what exactly is this extraordinary little creature, how does it ‘sail’, and what connects it to the rest of the fleet?

Read more →
September 19, 2026
In a nutshell – where I stand on the proposed Norfolk Island Marine Park
September 18, 2026
In a nutshell – where I stand on the proposed Norfolk Island Marine Park
September 18, 2026

I support the proposed expansion of Norfolk Marine Park and its renaming as Norfolk Island Marine Park. There is much to welcome – strong offshore protection, no mining, and recognition of the importance of sustainable local fishing. But I also have some reservations. Why does Cascade need to be removed from the Marine Park at all? How will more than 430,000 km² actually be monitored and enforced? How do we make sure Norfolk people have a genuine role in management? And, above all, how do we ensure that the enormous new park does not draw attention away from the small, stressed reef immediately beside us?

Read more →
September 18, 2026

Latest Posts

© 2026 All rights reserved.